Total Pageviews

Saturday, August 31, 2013

Did Lucas plagierize from 'Dune'?

     In 'Dune', written by Frank Herbert, "Fear is the mindkiller".

     I do not know how much material George Lucas consciously stole from Herbert's masterpiece of science fiction, but it seems like a lot.
     'Dune' a.k.a. 'Arrakis', is a desert planet.
     "Hey!  So is Tattooine!"
     Paul Atreides has some special powers.
     "Hey!  So does Luke Skywalker!"
    
     Both Dune and Star Wars involves a princess.

     Shall I continue?

     Dune was first published in 1965, but Star Wars came out in 1977,

     Dune has an Emperor, and so does Star Wars.

     Being a sci-fi geek, and into Star Trek, I would imagine that George Lucas would have read Dune, but I can't be sure.

     Dune has mammoth sandworms, and 'Empire Strikes Back' has a mammoth worm living in an asteroid, which makes no sense.  How can a worm live there with no air?

     The other thing I keep thinking about is, "Hey!  Lord of The Rings has a little green guy, and so does Star Wars!"

     Last but not least, "Hey!  Flash Gordon has scrolling type in perspective and so does Star Wars!"   ( I'm not kidding.  It's true.  Go watch Flash Gordon on youtube.  You'll even see electricity out of robot's hands. )